Legal News of the Day.

SC: Court cannot refuse to hear a bail application on the merit, saying the accused went back on

promise to settle.


Case Name : G Selvakumar vs State of Tamil Nadu


The Supreme Court has observed that a court cannot refuse to hear a bail application on merits on the

ground that the accused had failed to comply with the settlement offer made earlier and therefore set

aside an order passed by the Madras High Court which dismissed a bail application on the ground that

the accused had gone back on the promise to settle.

*The case arose out of an FIR registered over allegations of criminal breach of trust, cheating etc. and

the accused had sought for an interim bail by stating that he will settle the disputes relating to the

payment of money after he was released. But later the accused told that he was having difficulties in

paying the money due to certain domestic circumstances. The High court did not appreciate this

response and stated that the accused should have prayed for a regular bail instead of an interim bail if

he knew that he would not be in a position to make the payment and that he could not ask for

conversion of interim bail into regular bail. The HC dismissed the bail application.


The accused filed Special Leave Petition in the Supreme Challenging this order. The Supreme Court held

that the High court should have hear the bail application and should not have dismissed the same on the

ground that the accused had gone back on the promise made to the High Court. The Supreme Court

bench also stated that it did not intend to send the matter back to the High Court for fresh consideration

and that the accused should be released on bail subject to the satisfaction of the trial court.

Recent Posts

See All

Legal News of the Day.

Corruption In Judiciary Worse Than That In Public Departments: Madras HC Calls For Strengthening Of Vigilance System, Surprise Visits, Inspections. The conscience of this Court would not permit it, if

Legal News of the Day.

Karnataka HC: Registration of FIR not required on secret information about a crime which is about to occur. The court observed while dismissing the bail applications of few persons accused under the N

Legal News of the Day.

States Can Provide In-Service Quota In PG-Super Speciality Medical Courses: Kerala HC Observing that the States have the power to provide quota for in-service candidates in PG-Super Speciality medical

©2020 by LAWBHARAT. Proudly created with Wix.com